The Truth About AI in the Amazon Community

by | Nov 3, 2023

In the ever-evolving e-commerce landscape, Amazon reigns as the juggernaut of online marketplaces, luring millions of sellers into its fold. With the advent of artificial intelligence (AI), Amazon sellers have gained a powerful tool to enhance their product listings and boost sales. But, a concerning issue has emerged: an obsession with trends at the expense of customer-centricity.


In this op-ed we explore the motivations driving Amazon sellers to fiercely pursue AI trends. We’ll also provide practical solutions for sellers to harness AI as a valuable tool rather than rely on it as an overarching strategy.


The Allure of AI-Promised Shortcuts


It is no secret that AI technologies can provide sellers with invaluable insights and suggestions. Unfortunately, many Amazon agencies tend to push quick-fix narratives and tools that are widely ineffective in standing out or speaking to ideal target markets. 


So what gives exactly? Why are Amazon sellers gung-ho to drop dollars and common sense on all things AI when the blatantly obvious answer to many of their selling woes rests in the hands of their shoppers?


To fully understand why sellers tend to flock to trends instead of getting down and dirty with market research, we have to dig deeper and understand the buyer psychology of Amazon sellers at large. Most sellers jolt to selling on Amazon as a means to sell products and make money. Low bar to entry, quick initial sales, and seemingly decent returns on initial investment mean sellers get caught up in the bright, shiny object syndrome and tend to bypass marketing strategy before hitting upload to their product listings.


But, given that Amazon consistently prefers brands and branded content, recognizing AI as a tool rather than a total replacement is more advantageous to sellers looking to differentiate and sweep the market.


With the influx of Amazon AI listing tools, sellers have grown complacent, thinking of AI as a shortcut to success. They mistakenly believe AI can magically uncover compelling copy and keywords without thoroughly understanding their customers. Essentially, online sellers rush to trends because they don’t understand or recognize the power of brand building. You can’t exactly blame them when the community they immerse in jumps on trends as fast as bees find honey.


What’s FOMO Got to Do With It?


How often have you peered into an Amazon Facebook Group only to find the newest and latest tool or agency being repped by the group guru? The truth? Too many to count.


The fear of missing out, or FOMO, is a powerful force that drives Amazon sellers to hop on the trend-chasing bandwagon. They witness thought leaders and gurus touting new AI tools and competitors reaping seemingly ‘quick profits’ from the facade of AI. Have you ever noticed that AI results are generic, fluffy, and lack specificity? Brands tend to sound the same, and have side-swiped a unique brand story when they rush to AI as a total solution. Why? Because AI pumps out mass content. It’s marketed as a magical tool, and disguised as an expert solution.


AI marketing is expected to be a $107.5 billion industry by 2028 (Source: Statista – Marketing Value of AI in Marketing)


Neglecting the Customer, the Biggest Amazon Seller Mistake


Amazon Customers


In the rush to chase Amazon AI trends, listing content is riddled with trigger words and mundane copy in a rinse-and-repeat narrative. Ironic considering all seller’s need to do is engage in the vital practice of customer-centricity. You know, the one thing that matters most when building a brand…


The customer’s voice, preferences, and demands become secondary concerns. Instead of providing solutions that genuinely address customers’ needs, sellers prioritize quick wins based on trends that are often short-lived. 


How Amazon Agencies Play A Role in Chasing Trends That Don’t Last


The rise of Amazon as a global e-commerce giant has given birth to a burgeoning industry of Amazon agencies and consultants. These agencies claim to offer expertise in navigating the intricate world of Amazon, promising to help sellers build successful brands and understand the psychology of buyers on the platform.


However, beneath the veneer of expertise, there is a growing concern that many of these agencies perpetuate the use of tools and tactics that may not truly teach effective brand-building or buyer psychology. 


Amazon agencies often sell their services as the golden ticket to success on the platform. AI is no exception. We’ve seen countless AI listing software pop up in the last ten months. The reality is half or more won’t survive.


These tools encompass everything from AI-powered copywriting, AI keyword optimization, AI product listings, AI graphics, and more to help boost CTRs and conversion. While some of these tools can be genuinely valuable, others may scratch the surface of the complexities of building a brand and understanding buyer psychology.


Recently a well-known thought leader was so proud to advertise his Amazon AI software, he didn’t consider well enough the results before proudly displaying the AI generated Amazon listing.


The results? The title’s first phrase was riddled with sales copy clearly against Amazon’s code of conduct. Sure, it may seem like a small infraction. But imagine brands with extensive product lines who don’t have time or knowledge to meticulously scan each result. Can you say listing suppression?


But guess what, sadly sellers didn’t notice the mistake in the sample title. The thought leader behind the tool mattered more than the tool itself. And that is the cold, hard truth about influence in the Amazon community.


One common criticism is that many Amazon agencies prioritize quick fixes and shortcuts over long-term, sustainable strategies. For example, in previous years, they may have advocated for black hat tactics, such as artificially inflating product reviews or keyword stuffing, which may have lead to temporary success but also resulted in account suspensions and damage to a brand’s reputation in the long run. These older tactics bypassed the importance of building a genuine, trustworthy brand, which is now the cornerstone of success on the platform.


Furthermore, Amazon agencies often overemphasize the importance of data-driven decision-making without adequately teaching sellers how to interpret and act on the data effectively. The result is that businesses become dependent on the thought leaders or tools provided by these agencies rather than developing a deep understanding of their target audience’s psychology and the nuances of brand building. 


Amazon’s complex algorithmic landscape can be intimidating. Agencies sometimes exploit this fear by offering quick solutions that may not truly align with a brand’s unique identity and values. It sounds effective to say your AI listing software can impact CTR by X % and then loosely provide general data to back it up. Many times, sellers are distracted by fluffy information and tend to look the other way because they’ve come to rely too heavily on thought leaders and agency personas. Another harsh reality.


In essence, Amazon agencies sometimes create a culture of dependency, whether on AI or other tools and solutions. Businesses become reliant on external tools and expertise rather than developing a deep understanding of their brand, products, and customers. This can hinder their ability to adapt to changing circumstances and stand out in a crowded marketplace.


And before we rile up the Amazon community, it’s important to note that not all Amazon agencies perpetuate useless AI tools or short-term thinking. Some reputable agencies prioritize ethical practices, long-term brand building, equipping sellers with the knowledge and skills necessary to succeed independently. These agencies focus on building genuine, customer-centric brands and understanding the intricacies of buyer psychology on Amazon, fostering long-term relationships between businesses and their customers. Sure, they lean on AI to glean insights, perform competitor research, and draft foundational messaging, but the difference is they know not to rely on it.


Actionable Solutions for a Customer-Centric Amazon Selling Approach


To rectify this situation, Amazon sellers must embark on a path that prioritizes customer-centricity without solely relying on thought leaders, gurus, fluffy tools, expensive software, or AI. That said, we wholeheartedly agree some tools are necessary; we don’t dispute that. But our message is simple: be choosy, not trendy.


How To Craft A Customer-Centric AI Strategy


Amazon sellers should shift their focus from chasing trends to developing a customer-centric AI strategy. AI can be harnessed to deeply understand customers’ buying behaviour, preferences, and pain points. Lean on AI to perform market research, craft buyer personas, and glean insights into pain points and psychological triggers that make your target market act. This deep understanding should guide product offerings and marketing strategies.


Instead of alienating loyal customers by jumping on fleeting trends, sellers should utilize AI to identify trends that can be integrated into their product offerings while staying true to their core customer-centric values. This may mean you invest time and research before listing a product for quick sales.


Because the e-commerce landscape is in constant flux, and AI technologies evolve rapidly. Sellers should invest in their knowledge and expertise to stay informed and make decisions regarding AI tools and strategies with confidence. We are by no means saying to stop learning AI or put it on the back burner. We’re saying to stop idolizing tools when your energy can be better spent learning buyer psychology and market research.

How to Master Buyer Psychology Before Jumping on the Amazon AI Bandwagon


Amazon buyer psychology


Buyer psychology encompasses the various factors, emotions, and decision-making processes that influence a customer’s purchase choices. By honing in on buyer psychology, Amazon sellers can tailor their strategies to meet their customers’ needs and preferences, ultimately increasing sales and building a loyal customer base. The best part? Understanding buyer psychology can help you leverage Amazon AI software and tools to the best of their ability instead of glazing over the most important piece to your Amazon sales: your customers.


Emotional Triggers: Many purchasing decisions are driven by emotions. Shoppers often buy based on how a product makes them feel. Understanding the emotional triggers behind your target audience can help you craft marketing messages and product listings that resonate with their desires and aspirations.


Social Proof: People tend to trust products that others have tried and reviewed positively. Positive reviews and ratings can be powerful motivators for potential buyers. Encouraging and managing reviews on your Amazon listings can significantly impact buyer psychology.


Scarcity and Urgency: Creating a sense of urgency or scarcity can drive impulse purchases. Limited-time offers, low-stock notifications, and flash sales are all tactics that play on buyer’s’ fear of missing out.


Price Sensitivity: Amazon shoppers are naturally price-sensitive. Understanding what price points your target audience is willing to pay for a product can help you price your items competitively.


Trust and Credibility: Building trust with your customers is crucial. Clear and accurate product descriptions, reliable shipping, and excellent customer service contribute to your brand’s credibility and influence buyer psychology positively.


Visual Appeal: High-quality images and product presentation can significantly impact purchasing decisions. An appealing visual display can capture attention and evoke a desire to own the product. Contrary to popular Amazon seller sentiment, we don’t beleive AI will replace skilled graphic designers, or copywriters. 


How to Leverage Buyer Psychology In Your Amazon Marketing Strategy



Now that we’ve covered the basic principles of buyer psychology, let’s explore how Amazon sellers can harness this knowledge to their advantage without relying so heavily on artificial intelligence to craft me-too outcomes.

Market Research: Start by conducting thorough market research to understand your target audience. Identify their needs, preferences, pain points, and motivations. Use this information to create buyer personas that represent your ideal customers. Join Facebook groups, seek out subreddits, peer into Quora responses, and perform surveys and quizzes to learn about what makes your target market tick, and therefore add to cart.


Create a Brand Story: Share the story of your brand and products with potential customers. This humanizes your brand and allows buyers to connect emotionally with your products. Storytelling can also differentiate you from competitors.


Utilize A/B Testing: Experiment with different elements in your product listings and marketing campaigns. A/B testing allows you to compare various approaches to see what resonates best with your audience. Test elements like product titles, images, descriptions, and pricing.


Stay Informed and Adapt: The e-commerce landscape is ever-evolving. Stay updated on industry trends, Amazon policies, and the shifting preferences of your target audience. Continuously adapt your strategies to remain competitive. And yes, that means keeping up with changes in technology and AI.


Understanding and leveraging buyer psychology is essential for Amazon sellers aiming to succeed in a highly competitive marketplace. By empathizing with your target audience, understanding psychological triggers, and maintaining trust and credibility, you can connect with buyers on a deeper level and drive sales.




AI, when used thoughtfully, can be a powerful ally for Amazon sellers. However, it’s crucial to resist the siren call of trends and return to the fundamental principles of customer-centricity. 


Sellers who harness AI to understand what makes their customers tick, make data-driven decisions, and prioritize long-term sustainability will not only be able to follow trends but also set them. By refocusing on customer demands, sellers can ensure that AI becomes a tool to genuinely meet customers’ needs and expectations, fostering lasting success instead of a false sense of security that’s short-lived.


What do you think about how Amazon sellers leverage AI? Trendy or customer centric? Share this article and let’s open the conversation.


Looking to speak to a specific target market and boost sales? We can help. Now offering free Amazon listing copywriting with the purchase of any of our Amazon graphic design packages. Contact us today to get started.